jz
Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
jzMember
Mark – thanks for the advice. I have been trying to get in touch with the USC physicians you referred to, but having some insurance authorization delays which is ever so frustrating. Getting authorizations is such an unrelenting process, I wish the doctors could review the case while we’re getting the authorization so there isn’t so much delay. Sigh. Sorry for the vent.
PCL – on the food, we have been doing a lot of cooking and nutrition adjustments at home. We never ate much meat (grew up by the ocean so fish is our staple) so Dad has been eating even less because he feels better without much meat. Instead we keep up his protein with fish and different types of beans. We are on the same page as you on not spending time or money on the herbal medicines. There is too much uncertainty there for us to feel comfortable putting that into our bodies. We are mostly focused on finding a balanced diet that gives him the strength to fight this disease and helps to cleanse out any toxins that have been accumulating in his liver which are hard to flush out on its own. So we generally stick to a very vegetable (both cooked and uncooked) and fruit diet, supplemented heavily with protein from fish and beans, and carbs from sources such as taro, yam and oatmeal. My parents also like soybean milk so we make it fresh everyday. It’s a great substitute for milk and very easy to make. It also doesn’t have any refined sugar or other processed items, which based on my limited nutrition understanding, helps with nutrient absorption as well.
jzMemberThank you all again for the wonderful advice and support, this forum is such a silver lining in this process.
Bruce – incredibly helpful info on the staging, I believe this is the first time I have a clear understanding of how the staging of this cancer works! I had read the NCCN guidelines and thought the oncologist’s staging response was indicating more advanced disease than my Dad’s case, and your explanation gives me a better understanding. I will have this in my back pocket next time I talk to Dr. Finn, though I doubt this will change his recommendation for treatment – he seems to take the approach that once there is evidence of recurrence, it’s not relevant what the staging is or what symptoms are present, it’s more important to just talk treatment. While I understand his perspective, I still feel that patients have the right to know. So thank you for this!
PCL – thanks for the articles, I will read them to get a better understanding for RFA vs. surgery. I am miffed that Dr. Finn (oncologist) didn’t send us for an appointment with Dr. Busuttil (surgeon) because my first inclination was to ask Dr. Busuttil what his thoughts are on surgery. Dr. Finn thought surgery could be challenging given the tumors are in two different locations and that with recurrence, it’s going to need systemic treatment like chemo. But then he recommended RFA w/o follow up chemo. Ugghh, now I think about his logic, it’s making less sense… I am working on getting a second opinion from USC based on Mark’s suggestions, in addition to talking to other hospitals in the country.
To your point, we feel fortunate this was caught early and want to continue learning and working on treating this disease. Since the diagnosis, we as a family have been doing a lot of learning, about this disease, about the liver in general, nutrition, exercise, attitude etc. As you know, there’s a lot of medical knowledge that we are constantly learning and digesting and applying to my Dad’s treatment. My Dad used to drink and smoke in his younger days but has stopped both for years now, and he has not had Hepatitis B. Now we have adopted a much healthier lifestyle, both on foods and exercise, but also as it pertains to work and stress etc. Nothing more important than staying healthy and time together as a family!
All the best,
JuliejzMemberThank you all for the helpful responses, and the information on this topic. We are primarily interested in doing the testing to find more information for Dad’s treatment, and I haven’t really thought about the genetic implications for us kids. I will look into it more and talk to my Dad’s doctors to see what is appropriate. Thanks!
Julie
jzMemberMark, thank you for the info on RFA. I will report back on what the UCLA radiologist recommends after we meet with him, hopefully soon!
Best of luck with your upcoming RFA!
Julie
jzMemberThank you everyone for your warm welcome and good wishes, it’s quite the blessing to have found this forum and such a wonderful supportive group of people. In the short span of time since I have been exploring this site, I have learned so much from all of your posts, and although each person’s experience is different, the information we have garnered has been remarkably useful for me and my family, in considering next steps and being prepared for upcoming meetings with doctors. A very sincere and heartfelt thank you, and our best wishes for everyone who’s fighting this!
PCL – thanks for the very helpful info you have shared. Below is more info on my Dad’s case. I was also struck by two of your comments which I thought I’d throw out before I forget. First is your comment on my Dad’s oncologist not being specialized in treating cholangiocarcinoma. I wonder how you think I can find out more about what his experience is – we were “assigned” to him after my Dad had his resection with Dr. Busuttil and was told by him that Dr. Finn sees many cases of cholangio. Second is a comment you made in response to another of my posts – you had referred to ablation as a palliative, not curative, procedure. I wonder if you could refer me to any publications you have come across that I can read to understand ablation and its impact on tumors, because as I was thinking about it, it seemed to me that if RFA could lead to necrosis, then how is it markedly different from resection? On this last point, I just got word from Dr. Choti’s office at the JHokpins (I had sent my Dad’s medical files to him for a review) which says he believes my Dad can undergo resection as the next step. This is a totally new development so we are just absorbing it…
In response to your questions on my Dad’s background – we are immigrants from China but we kids mostly grew up in California. My Dad is 63 this year, and quite healthy and active otherwise. Even now, he insists on tending to his garden, planting new trees now the weather is warmer, and doing a lot of other activities, though since his surgery he has started doing more reading as well so he can rest in between more physically demanding activities.
The mass was discovered in autumn 2011, but initially the radiologists diagnosed it as a cyst, then UCLA thought it was heptocellular carcinoma. Dr. Busuttil recommended resection even though biopsy wasn’t done because he felt the size of the tumor and its location was reasonable for resection regardless of what type of tumor. It was only from the pathology report after the surgery that we learned the disease to be cholangiocarcinoma and not heptocellular carcinoma. The surgery was done in March 2012 and straightforward from our understanding – the tumor was in Segment 6 so it was taken out along with the gallbladder (gallbladder was normal). There was a 1cm negative margin and no lymph node. We weren’t given the staging, although when I asked the oncologist last Wednesday what my Dad’s staging is now given his recurrence, he said Stage III or IV which seems quite an aggressive staging to me after looking at the NCCN guidelines. The two new lesions were discovered in his CT in January 2013 and they are 1.1cm and 1.2 cm, one located in Segment 7 and the other located in Segment 4/8. My limited understanding is that the Segment 4/8 one is the harder one for resection, though I’m eager to hear what Dr. Choti has to say given he seems to believe resection is possible.
That is the short summary of my Dad’s case – as of now, the UCLA oncologist has recommended ablation because the tumors are small and in locations that he believes are reasonable for ablation. I first asked him about resection and he seemed to think surgery is too invasive when ablation could achieve the same result without as much damage to the body. Then I asked him about follow up chemo after ablation and he said that it wouldn’t make sense because once the tumors are gone then there is no marker for tracking the efficacy of the chemo drugs. I get what he’s saying, but given that it’s fairly certain that there will be cancerous cells lurking after ablation, I am going to push him more to consider whether adjuvant/maintenance therapy is appropriate.
I understand that each person’s case is different, but as always, your input and guidance will be much appreciated. Thanks!!
Julie
jzMemberMark, thank you for sharing your experience with me, I appreciate it very much. I understand your reluctance to share given we are all patients and not doctors, but for me, the information gives me more guidance for questions to ask the doctors and issues to explore with them. So thank you!
PCL, I appreciate your feedback on RFA and adjuvant therapy. I saw your also responded to my post in Introductions so I will combine my responses and do that in one post under that thread. Thanks!!
jzMemberBruce,
Thank you for the additional info on adjuvant therapy, I found reading that post to be very helpful.
We are planning to talk to more doctors about the ablation possibility. Interestingly, I heard back from Dr. Choti at JHopkins after I sent him my Dad’s medical files, and he is recommending that my Dad go with surgery (which would make it my Dad’s second resection). This is a totally new development as the onoclogist we’ve been seeing at UCLA had said that surgery is not the preferred route. I am going to explore this more with other doctors!! I understand that each person’s case is different, but if you have any input from your experience, I’d love to hear it.
All the best to you and your wife, and I hope the CT scan discussion on Monday will bring good news!!
Julie
jzMemberRandi, Eli,
I realize this thread is from a while ago, and I hope you are both doing well!
Wanted to follow up on ask which genetic clinics you went to for the testing. My Dad has a recent recurrence after resection last year and I wanted to send some of his tissue sample for testing in case they can be useful for his treatments.
Thanks much!
JuliejzMemberBruce, Holly,
I was just catching up on this conversation thread, and found your explanations to be very helpful in understanding this disease, so I wanted to say thank you.
Holly, I hope your surgery went smoothly, and you are recovering well! Given the good response to chemo, hopefully the surgery will only make the good better!
Bruce, I hope your wife is doing better with the chemo treatment as well. I’m curious if the doctors have changed their mind on radiation given her current progress. My Dad has two recurrent tumors (~1cm each) and we were recommended to go with ablation first, but the doctor also said he did not suggest chemo afterwards as an adjuvant/maintenance b/c if the ablation is successful then there would be nothing to track the response of the cancerous cells to chemo. Based on you and Holly’s explanations, I get the sense that the cancer cells may be lurking in the liver even if it doesnt show up with imaging given they are so microscopic. I just wonder if you can share your knowledge on how doctors decide which patients to proceed with adjuvant and which ones not – or is it really just a treatment philosophy that varies by the doctor?
Thanks!!
Julie
jzMemberBob & Nancy, Mark,
Thank you SO much for the wonderful advice and guidance. The info you provided is invaluable. We have just been relying on the advice of the oncologist Dr. Finn at UCLA but I am definitely going to reach out to the doctors at USC for second opinions.
Currently, Dr. Finn suggested that my Dad do some form of ablation (we are going to meet with a radiologist to discuss) on the two lesions given they are relatively small in size (~1cm each), but he also said that if the ablation is successful then he would not recommend chemo b/c there would be nothing to track the progress of the disease once the tumors are gone. I know there is controversy on whether adjuvant/maintenance chemo works so I’d be eager to hear what the USC doctors have to say. I’d also welcome your advice based on your experiences (with the understanding of course that each person’s situation is different).
Again, thank you for your help, and my best best wishes for Jeff and Mark’s treatments!!
Julie
jzMemberMarion and Mark – thanks so much for the info!
Mark – I’m sorry to hear of your recurrence, I hope you are receiving good treatment and my best wishes to you!! If you don’t mind sharing, what doctors did you consult with at UCLA and USC? My Dad’s oncologist at UCLA is currently Dr. Richard Finn, and the surgeon for his resection last year was Dr. Busuttil. Dr. Finn has suggested starting with RFA for my Dad’s recurrent tumors (both ~1cm) but I would like to get second opinions so will reach out to USC. If there are doctors there you have had good experiences with, I’d love to know.
Thanks!!
Julie
February 13, 2013 at 4:00 pm in reply to: Road Map & Systemic CCA Chemotherapy,Targeted Therapy & Options #58575jzMemberMarion and Lisa,
Thank you both so much for the response and guidance. This family here is really quite incredible, and I’m so thankful to have all of your support.
Lisa, you are so brave, and thank you for the offer to help. I will give you a call later today! Thanks!!
Julie
February 12, 2013 at 11:15 pm in reply to: Road Map & Systemic CCA Chemotherapy,Targeted Therapy & Options #58576jzMemberPercy,
Thank you SO much for this information. I am new to this site and have found so much of the posts’ info to be incredibly helpful, including this one.
My Dad’s ICC recurred earlier this year (Jan 2013) after he had a resection in March 2012. We are going to see the oncologist at UCLA tomorrow to discuss treatment plans, and I’ve found this info you posted to be a great resource. I’m preparing a list of questions to ask the oncologist tomorrow, and I wonder if you have suggestions for what we definitely should be asking.
Just a quick background on my Dad’s situation – he is 63, had a 5cm tumor resected from his right lobe in March 2012, and two new lesions (~1cm each) popped up on segment 7 and 4/8. He’s otherwise healthy, has a great appetite and is active.
His main symptoms are skin itchiness which has mostly subsided after he started paying more attention to the foods that he eats. I know there aren’t any western medicine protocols for nutrition in the recovery process, but we’ve started reading up a lot on nutrition after he started realizing that certain foods just made him feel so much better and since then his skin itchiness has been very infrequent. Sorry I’m rambling. As I was saying earlier, I’d love to hear your thoughts on relevant questions to ask the oncologist. Our oncologist is nice, but he’s really hard to connect with – I always feel like I need to ask him the right questions or else we don’t get all the necessary information.
Thanks!!!!!
Julie
-
AuthorPosts